Curtis Campogni unseated Pinellas County School Board member Dawn Peters by 712 votes. The countywide at-large District 3 seat represents Clearwater families alongside the rest of Pinellas County.

Precinct-level data, first reported by Beacon Media, shows the sharpest reversal came in Tarpon Springs. Four years ago, Peters led her opponent there by 2,158 votes. This time she trailed Campogni in every Tarpon Springs precinct, losing the city by 450 votes.

"There's no doubt that mattered," Campogni said, according to Beacon Media reporter Jeffrey S. Solochek. "Tarpon definitely shifted."

School closures drove the backlash

The anger traces to an Oct. 13 Pinellas County School Board vote to close six under-capacity campuses, the Tampa Bay Times reported. The list included Tarpon Springs Fundamental Elementary.

The board acted despite requests from a portion of the Tarpon Springs community for a postponement. Board member Lisa Cane moved to delay the vote until Oct. 27 to let more people weigh in. Her motion died without a second.

Sunset Hills Elementary supporters walked out of the boardroom after the failed delay, some in tears, others in anger. "We just got kicked out of our school," parent Irene Romero said as she departed, the Times reported.

Peters, then vice chairperson of the board, supported moving forward. "Giving everyone a decision tonight will help everyone move forward," she said at the meeting, according to the Times. Beacon Media described Peters as having "angered many Tarpon Springs residents over the way she dealt with their concerns" about the closure proposals.

From 14,000-vote win to 712-vote loss

Peters won the seat by more than 14,000 votes in 2022, running as a conservative outsider supporting parental rights and the Moms for Liberty agenda, according to Beacon Media. Overall, she lost 53 precincts this year that she carried in her first campaign.

Pinellas voters trended more Democratic this cycle. Campogni had the backing of several left-leaning and moderate groups, Beacon Media reported.

Campogni, 42, advanced to the Nov. 3 general election after finishing second in the Aug. 18 primary with about 59,000 votes, behind Peters. Beacon Media described him as working in social services for youths.

Peters declines recount

The final margin of 712 out of 350,156 ballots fell below 0.5%, triggering a mandatory recount under state law. Peters told the Pinellas County Elections Office she would not contest the results.

Election Supervisor Julie Marcus praised Peters and her decision. Marcus said via email that she appreciated "Ms. Peters' trust in our electoral process."

Peters did not respond to Beacon Media's requests for comment.

Campogni pledged to listen to the community. "I'm looking forward to working with the district and working with the board to solve problems," he said, according to Beacon Media.

The district still faces enrollment pressure. It has 41 elementary schools under 300 students and 45 schools below 60% capacity, the Times reported. Superintendent Kevin Hendrick has called those numbers unsustainable, and board members cautioned more closures are likely in future years.