Save the Garden says it will sue after the Clearwater City Council voted 3-2 Thursday, Nov. 5, to reject a petition opposing the South Garden Avenue transfer to the Church of Scientology. The group collected 7,577 valid signatures from Clearwater voters, exceeding the 7,067 required under the city charter to force council action.

Campaign director Brooks Gibbs told WFTS-TV the group is preparing to sue. "We have no choice but to defend the 7,500 signatures, and we have to do that in the court of law," Gibbs said. He said the group will need to raise money for the legal fight.

Three council members said state law prevented them from moving forward with the petition. Their position drew support from a Nov. 5 letter from the Florida Attorney General's office. Deputy Attorney General Greg Slemp wrote that state law "prohibits initiatives and referenda regarding development orders and land development regulations," according to Spectrum Bay News 9.

City Attorney Owen Kohler told the council that approving the repeal would violate Florida law because the state does not allow citizen petitions to change certain land development resolutions, WUSF reported.

Gibbs disagreed. He said council members were ignoring the city charter by refusing to repeal the ordinance or send the issue to a special election, Spectrum Bay News 9 reported.

Recess called after backlash

The meeting grew heated before the vote. Mayor Bruce Rector called a recess after audience outbursts, and several people walked out during council discussion, Spectrum Bay News 9 reported.

The outbursts followed comments from council member David Allbritton, who accused petition supporters of being motivated by opposition to Scientology rather than concern over the street. It was Allbritton's final meeting on the council, WUSF reported.

Rector said he would have preferred to repeal the ordinance or seek a court opinion on whether a referendum would violate the law, according to Spectrum Bay News 9.

Church says construction moves forward

The Church of Scientology issued a statement supporting the council's decision. The church said the attorney general "confirmed what the church has maintained all along: this petition is unlawful," according to Spectrum Bay News 9. The church's statement also said construction of L. Ron Hubbard Hall, an all-glass auditorium and plaza planned for the site, is moving forward.

Background: Save the Garden formed in 2025 to oppose a proposed transfer of a portion of South Garden Avenue to the Church of Scientology. The council passed the transfer ordinance in June, according to the Tampa Bay Times.

The Pinellas County supervisor of elections verified the petition signatures after Save the Garden asked that office to handle the count instead of the city clerk, the Tampa Bay Times reported.

The group had previously sued the city over an earlier petition effort but dropped that lawsuit after a judge denied a preliminary injunction, according to the Tampa Bay Times.